Yes, it is almost February, and only now have I decided my favorite beer of December. I do however have an excellent excuse: being terrible at making decisions! Synonymous with winter, December is heavy on barley-centric winter ales (and lagers), as well as other dark, warm beers, many in the barleywine style. I stopped by Barcade a while back and tried two beers, the He’Brew Jewbelation 12 and Dogfish Head Palo Santo. As advertised, the Jewbelation 12’s twelve malts and twelve hops proves a powerful and tasty mix, although I couldn’t help but feel that the beer’s 24 ingredients is more for garnering press than brewing a balanced beverage (as if anyone could pinpoint the distinct varieties of each hop and malt used). Having just read a New Yoker article about Dogfish Head featuring its Palo Santo and the rare wooden barrel used in its production, I had to try it. Only after it was handed to me did I realize the beer clocks in at 14% ABV! Palo Santo is woody, smoky, and seductively sweet, but the alcohol is simply too much, not only for someone interested in having more than three beers before needing to take a nap, but also for someone looking to fully taste their beer.
I did my best to try as many winter beers as possible this season, and found that in general I am not too excited with the style. Southern Tier, Smuttynose, and Pickled Santa (at Portland, ME’s excellent Vignola) were more complex, flavorful and made a better impression than others. Aside from “winter
” brews and barleywines, December is thick with rich, warming porters and stouts, my favorite of which is Brooklyn Black Chocolate Stout, a very dark, chocolaty imperial stout coming in at 10% ABV. For years now during the holidays, this beer has been by my side (no better companion at a family function than a delicious 10% beverage!) to the point where Christmas can no longer be complete without it. I welcome the day another beer can take its place, and almost saw that day recently when I tried the Smuttynose Imperial Stout. New Hampshire’s Smuttynose is quickly becoming one of my favorite breweries, and their take on an imperial stout, like their take on everything else, is done with a trademark blend of vigor and finesse, full-on flavor and balanced subtlety. Although Smuttynose Imperial Stout is sweeter and has less alcoholic bite (yet the same percentage), Black Chocolate Stout is too behemoth and magnanimous a beer to topple without a considerable variation on the style or leap in flavor. Garrett Oliver’s Stout is in many ways not versatile, being so dark, rich and strong, but if you’re in the mood for a beer as big as they come (or the perfect companion for a chocolate dessert, or simply as dessert itself!) look no further.
At the beach in July, no thanks. But home for the holidays …
Posted in Beer, Beer of the Month
Tags: Beer of the Month, Brooklyn Black Chocolate Stout, Dogfish Head Palo Santo, He'Brew Jewbelation 12, Pickled Santa, Smuttynose Imperial Stout, Vignola